Legendary singer Aretha Franklin died more than six years ago. However, it wasn’t until last year that a Michigan judge ruled a handwritten document discovered under her couch cushions was a valid will. This case illustrates the dangers of a so-called “holographic” will. It’s one where the entire document is handwritten and signed without the presence of a lawyer or witnesses.
Facts of the case
Initially, Franklin’s family thought she had no will. In that situation, her estate would have been divided equally among her four sons under the laws of intestate succession. A few months after she died, however, the family discovered two handwritten “wills” in her home.
The first, dated 2010 and found in a locked cabinet, was signed on each page and notarized. The second, dated 2014, was found in a spiral notebook under her couch cushions and was signed only on the last page. The two documents had conflicting provisions regarding the distribution of her homes, cars, bank accounts, music royalties and other assets, leading to a fight in court among her heirs. Ultimately, a jury found that the 2014 handwritten document should serve as her will.
Holographic wills can cause unexpected outcomes
Michigan, like many states, permits holographic wills. These wills, which don’t need to be witnessed like formal wills, must be signed and dated by the testator and the material portions must be in the testator’s handwriting. In addition, there must be evidence (from the language of the document itself or from elsewhere) that the testator intended the document to be his or her last will and testament.
Holographic wills can be quick, cheap and easy, but they can come at a cost. Absent the advice of counsel and the formalities of traditional wills, handwritten wills tend to invite challenges and interfamily conflict. In addition, because an attorney doesn’t prepare them, holographic wills tend to be less thorough and often contain ambiguous language.
If you need a will, contact your estate planning attorney for help. Having your will drafted by a professional can give you peace of mind knowing that your assets will be divided as you intended.
© 2024